Semantic Dependencies in Formal Ontologies

Ontologies often consist of complex logical theories. However, this complexity poses significant challenges during their development. A change to a class or the addition of an axiom may have significant implications for large parts of the ontology. This raises an important question for ontology developers: If we change the semantics of one term by altering an axiom, which other terms in the ontology may be affected and, thus, should be double-checked? Philosophically, there are strong arguments for semantic holism according to which the semantics of all terms in an ontology are interdependent. However, while semantic holism may be correct, from a practical point of view it is not helpful, because it is not feasible to double-check all terms and all axioms in an ontology each time a minor change is made. Thus, we use semantic dependency as a means to track whether changing the semantics of one term in an ontology may affect the semantics of another. E.g., in SNOMED CT, the class Type 2 diabetes mellitus depends semantically on Endocrine disorder, but not on Procedure declined by patient. In this talk, we will present different approaches to formalizing a notion of semantic dependency between the nonlogical symbols (e.g., class names and role names) in an ontology. In addition to theoretical considerations, we will also demonstrate the practical use of this approach. To this end, we will present a tool capable of extracting dependencies even from large ontologies and show how these can then be used to identify potential, previously undetected errors in those ontologies.
Fabian Neuhaus and Martin Glauer
Last modified: Mon Nov 16 2026